Search
Create an Account - | Customer Service | Healthcare Professionals | My Zone |INTERNATIONAL 
 
Forums > Zone Living Forums > Zone Philosophy
Subject: Which Fish Oil?

You are not authorized to post a reply.   

Author Messages
marshmallowcreme User is Offline
Posts:0
Newbie
Newbie
06/15/2004 9:59 PM Alert 
Is the Zone Perfect fish oil the same fish oil as the OmegaRX fish oil that Dr. Sears sells? If it's not as pure, why would Dr. Sears advocate its sale at Zone Perfect? and if it is the same, why is it so much cheaper?
jaydpiii User is Offline
Posts:0
Newbie
Newbie
06/16/2004 10:44 AM Alert 
[quote:df56a389ab="marshmallowcreme"]Is the Zone Perfect fish oil the same fish oil as the OmegaRX fish oil that Dr. Sears sells? If it's not as pure, why would Dr. Sears advocate its sale at Zone Perfect? and if it is the same, why is it so much cheaper?[/quote:df56a389ab] Didn't you also post this in HEALTH Forum? Dr. Sears is NOT associated with Zone Perfect. Not the same stuff. Zone Perfect is NOT IFOS. Can't say about quality. If you want something good quality, but not IFOS, try Natural Factors, Rx Omega-3.
Courageous User is Offline
Posts:0
Newbie
Newbie
07/11/2004 10:53 AM Alert 
John, It's not clicking for me right now....what does IFOS stand for? Thanks :)
jaydpiii User is Offline
Posts:0
Newbie
Newbie
07/11/2004 12:21 PM Alert 
[quote:ea3b4ee753="Courageous"]John, It's not clicking for me right now....what does IFOS stand for? Thanks :)[/quote:ea3b4ee753] IFOS (International Fish Oil Standards?) Though I believe, and many here do also, that Natural Factors meets the IFOS standards, they have never submitted their product for the very expensive testing done by the one site promoted here that publishes their results on the web. Several of us have contacted Natural factors, and they sent us their purity levels. According to them, and the levels they sent us, their product meets or exceeds IFOS. Another member of this forum contacted Natural Factors and inquired if their product was tested by an independant lab. That forum member, if I remember correctly, is satisfied, according to the answers received from Natural Factors. So, according to the numbers received - Natural factors is of similar purity levels to Dr. Sears. I just ordered another 4 bottles. One bottle only lasts 15 days - and at $14.00 per 120 capsules with free shipping and 10% discount - a good deal. (Though still very. very tough on our tiny, tiny budget!)
White Light User is Offline
Posts:0
Newbie
Newbie
07/11/2004 5:53 PM Alert 
Hi Again, [quote:8bb7314331="jaydpiii"][quote:8bb7314331="Courageous"]John, It's not clicking for me right now....what does IFOS stand for? Thanks :)[/quote:8bb7314331] IFOS (International Fish Oil Standards?) Though I believe, and many here do also, that Natural Factors meets the IFOS standards, they have never submitted their product for the very expensive testing done by the one site promoted here that publishes their results on the web. Several of us have contacted Natural factors, and they sent us their purity levels. According to them, and the levels they sent us, their product meets or exceeds IFOS. Another member of this forum contacted Natural Factors and inquired if their product was tested by an independant lab. That forum member, if I remember correctly, is satisfied, according to the answers received from Natural Factors. So, according to the numbers received - Natural factors is of similar purity levels to Dr. Sears. I just ordered another 4 bottles. One bottle only lasts 15 days - and at $14.00 per 120 capsules with free shipping and 10% discount - a good deal. (Though still very. very tough on our tiny, tiny budget!)[/quote:8bb7314331] To see the products that meet IFOS standard go to www.ifosprogram.com The test is not expensive as you sugest ,merely a few cents a bottle. Dennis was advised that all testing costs much the same. IFOS standards are the strictest in the world. You cant reach that standard with other testing but its certainly possible to reach WHO or CRN standard. As for ZP oil being a lot cheaper. when you consider it only has 1/2 the omega 3 of a genuine 40:20 it is NOT good value. at all White Light
jaydpiii User is Offline
Posts:0
Newbie
Newbie
07/12/2004 10:22 AM Alert 
[quote:0370be4621="White Light"]Hi Again,As for ZP oil being a lot cheaper. when you consider it only has 1/2 the omega 3 of a genuine 40:20 it is NOT good value. at all White Light[/quote:0370be4621] I just wanted to clarify: ZP is NOT Natural Factors. Natural Factors is at the 40:20 (desired, genuine) ratio. So NF is a good value.
Dennis User is Offline
Posts:1
Newbie
Newbie
07/13/2004 1:38 AM Alert 
[quote:65e73a1df4="White Light"]IFOS standards are the strictest in the world. You cant reach that standard with other testing but its certainly possible to reach WHO or CRN standard.[/quote:65e73a1df4] Just a note of clarification for other readers: It is very rare for any food or drug company to publish the results of product purity testing. Most processed food and drug products are required to have some level of contamination testing by government regulations. This is for the safety of the consumers. I credit Dr. Sears as the one who has led the way and applied pressure to the refined fish oil industry to make the results of their testing public. However, testing a product to a particular standard does not mean that the product is not better than the standard. It just means that the product is guaranteed to be at least as good as the standard. Any product that claims to meet a standard and did not, could not be sold. You can't economically test quality in. You have to start with a manufacturing process that is robust. Testing is a process monitoring tool to make sure that nothing in your manufacturing process has changed drastically. The AVERAGE long term quality is much more important for fish oil than if a single batch is higher or lower in quality. This is because the type of contamination that we are concerned about is the type that accumulates in the body over a long period of time. The AVERAGE quality of a fish oil product has more to do with the raw materials used (starting contamination levels) and the effectiveness of the manufacturing methods used to remove those contaminants.
White Light User is Offline
Posts:0
Newbie
Newbie
07/13/2004 5:13 AM Alert 
Hi Dennis, [quote:e18a1617b3="gofish"][quote:e18a1617b3="White Light"]IFOS standards are the strictest in the world. You cant reach that standard with other testing but its certainly possible to reach WHO or CRN standard.[/quote:e18a1617b3] Just a note of clarification for other readers: It is very rare for any food or drug company to publish the results of product purity testing. Most processed food and drug products are required to have some level of contamination testing by government regulations. This is for the safety of the consumers. I credit Dr. Sears as the one who has led the way and applied pressure to the refined fish oil industry to make the results of their testing public. However, testing a product to a particular standard does not mean that the product is not better than the standard. It just means that the product is guaranteed to be at least as good as the standard. Any product that claims to meet a standard and did not, could not be sold. You can't economically test quality in. You have to start with a manufacturing process that is robust. Testing is a process monitoring tool to make sure that nothing in your manufacturing process has changed drastically. The AVERAGE long term quality is much more important for fish oil than if a single batch is higher or lower in quality. This is because the type of contamination that we are concerned about is the type that accumulates in the body over a long period of time. The AVERAGE quality of a fish oil product has more to do with the raw materials used (starting contamination levels) and the effectiveness of the manufacturing methods used to remove those contaminants.[/quote:e18a1617b3] I must respectfully disagree with you. It is the contaminents in the batch you consume that effect you. Not the ones that went before. Would you really stick with a batch that tested dangerous to your health ? If Natural Factors could produce a 5 star batch at Iherb prices, I would switch tomorrow If SYW drops from its 5 star status and another TG supplier of 40:20 has one at a similar price, Again I change brands tomorrow. at US$18.75 for a months supply of a 5 star product I see no point in Gambling on the uncertified. Everybody is however free to make their own choice. White Light
You are not authorized to post a reply.
Forums > Zone Living Forums > Zone Philosophy > Which Fish Oil?


ActiveForums 3.6
Enter your email address:
Learn More
DrSears.com
Polyplus Sm
Helpful Tools
Popular Links
Related Products

A great way to stay In The Zone!
Start getting Zone recipes, tips, articles and exclusive promotions sent right to your inbox!

After you provide your email address we’ll send you a confirmation email. You can “opt-out” of this program at anytime by following the simple instructions provided at the end of every email we send you. We will never send too many emails (spam) and we’ll never sell of rent your email to another company.

If you are already registerd with ZoneDiet.com and are receiving emails from Dr. Sears Zone then you do not need to provide your email address to us at this time.

To assure your Zone emails reach your inbox, be sure to add our email address,
reply@zoneliving.com, to your address book.
Copyright 2007 by Zone Labs Inc        Privacy Statement | Terms Of Use | About Zone Labs | Contact Us | Affiliates | Press Room | Careers | Site Map